Review: Frontline, Advantage, and All Spot-On Treatments

Today I applied my last dose of Frontline on my large mixbreed dog Carmina.  I had already stopped using it on my Papillons because one, it did not work, two I was concerned about skin irritation.  After today, however, I will never apply spot-on treatments on ANY of them again.  Contrary to the instructions, I opened the Frontline packaging by making a slit with a pair of scissors.  I didn’t notice that I had accidentally cut the dosage packaging itself.  As I applied it to my dog, some of the medication leaked out onto my index finger.  I thought nothing of it at the time, then about half an hour later, my finger started burning and itching, and I started to not feel so well.  I still do not feel so well and my finger is burning like a chemical burn.

It took me a minute to figure out what was going on, then I remembered having to wash off the liquid from that same area on my hand.  All I could think was, I can’t believe I’ve been putting this stuff on my poor dogs!  Those poor Papillons especially with their sensitive skin must have been miserable.  It hurts and it makes you feel like crap.  So, as a result of inadvertent testing on humans, topicals are out.

I did some further research on topicals and found that the EPA is closely monitoring spot on treatments because of numerous reported incidents.  You can read the full EPA article here.

“The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is pursuing a series of actions to increase the safety of spot-on pesticide products for flea and tick control for cats and dogs. Immediately, EPA will begin reviewing labels and determining which ones need stronger and clearer labeling statements. EPA will also develop more stringent testing and evaluation requirements for both existing and new products. EPA expects these steps will help prevent adverse reactions from pet spot-on products.”
There have also been problems with counterfeited Frontline and Advantage medication earlier this year.  Click here for the full EPA warnings.

 

Better flea control methods!

I got this response to my first blog post/call for help from Riyo and Darcy’s first mom :-) I will go look for this stuff and try it out! Also was told by another Papillon expert to try something called Comfortis.:

Use a yard and house spray with IGR in it. Will be more expensive, but has a chemical in it that basically neuters fleas. Most sprays etc…only kill the adult fleas leaving the eggs, and other stages to hatch out and form into adults only to carry on the problem. IGR is an insect growth regulator that neuters them when they come into contact with it so the ones that continue to hatch out even after spraying will not be able to reproduce thus putting a kink in their life cycle. It may not totally stop the problem, but the IGR usually lasts for a while. Also, spray in the evening time near as sunset as possible. Sunlight breaks down the poisons and makes it not last as long and be less effective. Giving all night to begin killing is best. You should also repeat the treatment in 7 days with most sprays.

Yes, fleas are showing signs of getting immune to things that have been on the market for a while. That’s why we are always waiting for the next big break through product. Treating the dogs and the yard is the best you can do. Just be sure to be careful when looking into those newer products that claim to do multiple things all in one such as fleas, worms etc…They are often too harsh for toy dogs and cause an array of reactions from neurological to even death in some cases. I have also stuck with Advantage more than frontline as I know more dogs that have had issues with frontline from irritated skin to coat loss.